Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Churchill

πŸ“Œ Brand: Oliva Cigar Co.
πŸ“Œ Line: Serie V Melanio Maduro
πŸ“Œ Size: Churchill (7" Γ— 50)
πŸ“Œ Weight: 17.2 g
πŸ“Œ Age: 5 years
πŸ“Œ Origin: Nicaragua

‍ ‍Tasting Notes

  • Dark Chocolate – Rich, bittersweet cocoa with a smooth, luxurious character

  • Espresso – Deep roasted coffee notes bringing intensity and warmth

  • Black Pepper – Gentle but persistent spice adding depth to the profile

  • Molasses – Dark, natural sweetness balancing the richer tobacco flavours

First Impressions

The Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Churchill is certainly a cigar that creates expectations before the first flame even touches the foot. The Melanio name has become associated with some of Oliva's finest work, and the Maduro version promises an even richer interpretation of an already respected blend. The Churchill format is particularly appealing to me. There is something wonderfully traditional about a long cigar that gives the tobacco plenty of time to develop. The box-pressed shape adds a little elegance, while the dark Mexican San AndrΓ©s wrapper gives the cigar a rich, almost chocolate-brown appearance. The wrapper has a pleasant oily sheen, with a relatively smooth texture and an attractive finish. Pre-light aromas suggest dark chocolate, roasted coffee, earth, and a little natural sweetness. The cold draw brings similar characteristics, although the resistance feels slightly firmer than I would ideally prefer. Everything about the presentation suggests a premium smoking experience, and I am particularly interested to see how the Maduro wrapper influences the familiar Melanio character.

Smoking Experience

  • First Third – Opens with a rich combination of dark chocolate, espresso, and a gentle black pepper spice. There is a pleasant natural sweetness underneath, giving the profile a smooth and rounded character. The flavours are beautifully defined, with enough richness to make an immediate impression without becoming excessively powerful. However, the draw is slightly tight, requiring a little more effort than I would like. It doesn't completely spoil the opening, but it does prevent the smoke from flowing quite as effortlessly as it should.

  • Second Third – The espresso becomes more prominent, accompanied by dark cocoa, roasted earth, and a deeper molasses sweetness. The pepper settles into the background, allowing the richer Maduro characteristics to take centre stage. There is some lovely complexity here, with the flavours working together rather than competing for attention. Unfortunately, a slight bitterness begins to emerge, particularly around the roasted coffee notes. It isn't particularly aggressive, but it does interrupt the otherwise excellent balance. The draw also remains somewhat restrictive, limiting the overall smoke production.

  • Final Third – The profile becomes darker and more intense, with espresso, dark chocolate, and black pepper dominating. The molasses sweetness remains present but becomes less noticeable as the roasted flavours strengthen. There is still plenty of character, and the cigar maintains an enjoyable richness through the finish. However, the slight bitterness becomes more noticeable at times, and the tight draw continues to demand extra effort. Neither issue completely ruins the experience, but together they prevent what could have been an outstanding cigar from reaching its full potential.

Pairings

  • Alcohol – GlenDronach 18 Year Old Allardice Single Malt Scotch Whisky - Rich sherry sweetness, dark fruit, chocolate, and warming oak complement the cigar's espresso and cocoa character beautifully. The whisky's dried fruit richness provides a pleasant contrast to the slight bitterness, while its depth matches the intensity of the Maduro tobacco.

  • Tea – Taiwan Ruby Red No. 18 Black Tea - Its distinctive notes of cinnamon, mint, malt, and natural sweetness provide an interesting contrast to the cigar's darker roasted flavours. The tea has enough body to accompany the Melanio Maduro while offering a refreshing balance to the bittersweet finish.

Music Pairing

β€œSince I've Been Loving You” – Led Zeppelin - Rich, emotional, and full of beautifully controlled intensity. The gradual development of the guitar work feels particularly appropriate for the cigar's deepening chocolate and espresso flavours.

Final Thoughts

Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Churchill is a very enjoyable cigar that demonstrates why the Melanio name continues to command so much respect. The combination of dark chocolate, espresso, black pepper, and molasses creates a rich, satisfying profile with plenty of depth and character. What I particularly appreciate about this blend is the way the darker Maduro flavours develop throughout the smoke. The chocolate and coffee notes provide a strong foundation, while the natural sweetness brings balance and prevents the profile from becoming overwhelmingly heavy. There is enough complexity to keep the experience interesting, and the Churchill format allows plenty of time to appreciate the different layers. Unfortunately, two relatively minor but persistent issues prevent the cigar from achieving a higher score. The first is the draw. Although it is not completely obstructed, it remains slightly tighter than I would prefer throughout the smoke. This means working a little harder to produce a satisfying amount of smoke, which takes away from the relaxed experience I expect from a premium cigar. The second issue is the bitterness. It is not severe enough to make the cigar unpleasant, but it becomes noticeable during the second half, occasionally disturbing the otherwise excellent balance between roasted flavours and natural sweetness. Neither problem is disastrous on its own, and the tobacco remains enjoyable throughout. However, when combined, they prevent the Melanio Maduro Churchill from delivering the effortless, perfectly balanced smoking experience I was hoping for. Despite these imperfections, I would happily return to this cigar. The flavours are rich, the blend has genuine character, and there is plenty to appreciate. With a slightly more comfortable draw and a cleaner finish, this could easily have been something exceptional.

Final Score: 8/10

Why not a 10?
The draw was slightly tight, requiring more effort than ideal, while a mild bitterness occasionally disturbed the balance of the darker roasted flavours. An otherwise excellent cigar that fell just short of perfection.

Only cigars that deliver flawless draw, balance, flavour evolution, construction and satisfaction get a 10.

Next
Next

Intemperance Whiskey Rebellion 1794 Hamilton